I have attended and run games at Battle Group Boston's annual early spring miniature wargames convention, HAVOC, a number of times over the years. The convention was cancelled in 2020 and 2021 due to the pandemic, and I did not consider attending in 2022, either. Indeed, the last time I attended was in 2019, and that year heavy snow that weekend really cut down attendance. I wasn't planning on attending this year either, but a month or so before the show the organizers put out a call for more games. Up until 2019, when I had attended, I had made the roughly 2.5 hr drive to the convention, set up my game, run it, packed it up, and driven home the same day. The last time I did that, in ? 2018, I decided that was just too much for one day. In 2019, I stayed overnight in a not that nearby hotel with my freind Greg Hansen from HAHGS, and ran games Saturday afternoon and Sunday AM. I answered the email saying that I would run a couple of games, IF I could find someone to share a room with. The convention had relocated to a new venue, the Best Western hotel in Marlborough, MA, with on site rooms, restaurant, etc. It turned out that Greg was attending and had a room, so we shared it Saturday night. Good deal!
Saturday afternoon I ran a 28 mm Napoleonic game, set in Spain in 1809, "The Spanish Ulcer", using the new Valor and Fortitude rules (free from Perry Miniatures website).
We had 7 players, 4 Spanish and 3 "French" (which included a Division each of Rheinbund and Vistula Legion troops).
French cavalry charge a roughly equal number of Spanish cavalry; the French had a real quality advantage here. One of the players had to leave an hour before the game was scheduled to conclude, so I assigned him the Iberian horsemen! :-)
The Spanish cavalry punched above t5heir weight for a while, but ultimately both Divisions broke and ran... as expected.
The Spanish infantry were another matter. Although their quality was lower, and about 20% of the units were Militia, the advantage they had in numbers wound up more than compensating.
One Spanish Cavalry Division has already broken and run off the field, and the second, down to just one remaining unit, will soon follow!
Measuring command radius for the Spanish C-in-C.
The rules used were a variant of Feudal Combat Patrol by Buck Surdu; almost all of the outcomes in the game are governed by the cards in the deck that each player has. The Conquistadors had many combat advantages, but in the end they got bogged down in indecisive combats in the vegetation and made little progress. Many Maya fell, but so did quite a few of the "men of Steel". Surprisingly, all of my boys returned home to the village alive!
Edgar faced off against Devin, who was attending his first ever wargames convention. Naturally, the newcomer prevailed, the inferior Indian Cavalry being bolstered by the decidedly impressive Indian heavy chariots!
In the center, the Indian long bowmen loosed innumerable arrows, almost all to little effect (the phalangites were saving on 5+). They used the "Shoot and Scoot" to stay just out of reach of the fearsome Phalanx units as long as possible. When the pikes finally got stuck in, the Macedonian player scored few hits, and the Indians saved almost every one, despite many units needing a 9+ to save! With the Macedonian infantry frustrated, the win went to Porus after an Indian chariot smashed Alexander himself and his companions!
I had time to take a few quick pictures of other games on Sunday morning. Sci Fi Naval with Silent Death.
Battle of Sidi Rezegh, 1943, Axis and Allies miniatures.
Mark Morin was back with the Battle of Lake Texococo; Cortez actually constructed warships inland to seize control of the Lake and cut off the Aztec capitol.
The new site was a big upgrade, and hopefully will spur further growth of this venerable convention!
Looks like some great games there, Peter and a lot of fun had by all. The outcome of your Napoleonic encounter was a bit of a surprise!
ReplyDeleteThe way the rules work, the OOB for the Spanish infantry proved effective; the limited Militia units provided back up from the rear, where they were protected from most casualties. The rules allow for having inferior Generals for the Spanish, but that would have increased their numbers still further. The Spanish cavalry were seriously outclassed, but that allowed them to have the two extra units to use on the opposite flank.
DeleteLots of nice looking games!
ReplyDeleteChristopher
Thanks, Christopher!
DeleteWow, Spanish and more Spanish in the same week followed by a massive ancient game. So the new rules from the Perry brothers were a good event, will have to take a look. Glad the weather and lodging worked out for you.
ReplyDeleteThe rules are free and reasonable, and accomplish what they set out to do. The organization is a lot like Black Powder/Hail Caesar, with oodles of special rules in the army lists, which I find annoying.
DeleteI had not gotten far after downloading the almost original set. I will need to see how the rules look now, after a few month's play.
DeleteThere are a number of refinements, plus more army lists.
DeleteA nice variety of games there Peter and a good win to the Spanish which is always nice to see. At least it looked like the person in charge of the Spanish cavalry managed his early getaway, so your astute assignment of forces worked well there in spite of the Spanish win.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Lawrence. The Spanish Cavalry was largely crushed, but the "French" infantry was thrashed!
DeleteInterested to hear your overall take on Perry rules. I thought they had some nice ideas/systems but bit lacking overall, but I can see their attraction for large quick playing games.
ReplyDeleteI'll have more to say in another post. I prefer FoB/Battle Command, and I think they play just about as fast. My past experience with HAVOC attendees (granted probably 10 years ago) was that wasn't a style of game they tended to enjoy, which was one of my motivations for using V&F for this outing.
DeleteHard not to adjust to your audience.
DeleteExactly!
DeleteLooks like a great convention :)
ReplyDeleteWell worth the trip!
DeleteGreat result for the Spanish, haven't tried the Perry rules yet, I'll probably stick with Blackpowder as it will just confuse me! It does sound like a good convention!
ReplyDeleteBest Iain
There are certainly similarities between V&F and BP.
DeleteFor ordinary purposes. Field of Battle/Battle Command remain my rules of choice.
Very nice looking games and event!
ReplyDeleteBest wishes,
Jan
Thanks, Jan. A small convention, but definitely worthwhile!
Delete